There is much theory and little fact. We know they only take firstborn sons, just like Rumplestiltskin did.
More you might like
dean: *runs his hands through his hair and winks*
me: I would lay down my life for you
still absolutely unbelievable to me that the mixtape is only mentioned ONE time and it’s during the “it’s a gift” scene. we don’t see dean making it. we were never informed that he GAVE cas a mixtape. there was no setup to it and the only narrative point (besides deancas) was to get them to Talk and also get cas into dean’s room but that could have been. Anything????? Why mixtape why shot of hands. why zepp after “he was cute and he knew the words to every zeppelin song.” we know why. we KNOW